Yo beamers
I throw the tin gasket away and use Indian Head against the head and silcone on the intake.To me tin gasket is a pontenial place to suck air.I use 'cone'on the intake manifold so the it can be removed and replaced while leaving the gasket alone and ready to reuse.Some may disagree but my intake manifold has been off 3 times in ten years re-using the same gasket.
Agm&WarPony
at large out west...
Well I keep the tin gasket, to me its the key to reusability.
I silicone both sides of the asbestos gasket, this makes the gasket seal very well to the head and the metal sheet.
Since the metal sheet is installed with dimples facing out, I then put a dab of silicone ONLY around the dimples to the intake.
This makes the good seal where it needs it, but doesnt put so much silicone on the sheet so that when you pry the intake off, it pulls the sheet from the gasket, or the gasket off the head.
This counts on the sheer surface area of the silicone on the gasket to prevent it from tearing loose on future removal.
I tear my intake off fairly often, and Ive had the same gasket and metal piece on the engine for over 10 years. This with probably 5 removals.
I may one day make a sheet spacer with o-rings in it to be done with the gaskets forever. The only thing keeping me from doing it is what to do with the exhaust side of the equation.